
A revolution in English reading instruction has spread across the US, driven by state policies mandating a curriculum based on the Science of Reading (SoR). This framework requires teachers to prioritize specific literacy practices. Among the 5.3 million students affected, a significant portion are English Learners (ELs) and Multilingual Learners (MLs).
Teachers’ Voices Absent in Policy Decisions
Despite the direct impact on classrooms, the voices of frontline teachers have been largely absent from policy discussions. A review of state-by-state SoR policies revealed that MLs are often peripherally addressed or entirely absent. This oversight has led to negative consequences for these students when mandated curricula are implemented.
Bilingual and ESL educators have noticed that SoR-prescribed curricula don’t always meet the needs of MLs. Teachers struggle to balance state mandates with the unique literacy development requirements of their students. The “one-size-fits-all” approach of SoR curricula limits teachers’ ability to integrate other instructional strategies, hindering their professional agency.
Teachers Adapt to Support Multilingual Learners
A study by Escamilla and Strong (2024) documented the experiences of 77 educators implementing SoR curricula with MLs. While acknowledging the importance of foundational skills, teachers found the focus on English phonics interfered with other skill development. Dual language and bilingual program teachers expressed concern about the curriculum’s impact on biliteracy development.
In a case study by Gallagher et al. (2023), teachers who adapted their curriculum to be more student-centered and linguistically responsive saw better reading competence among their students.
Related Post: Cambridge Education Opens Doors for State School Students
The SoR movement has now reached federal policymakers, with the Science of Reading Act of 2026 passing the House of Representatives. As the READ ACT progresses through the Senate, concerns are growing among school leaders and researchers about its impact on literacy education.
Federal Legislation Advances Amid Teacher Concerns
The Science of Reading Act of 2026 passed the House of Representatives on September 21, 2026, while its counterpart, the READ ACT, is under Senate review. This development has raised concerns among educators and researchers focused on literacy education.
Teachers’ Concerns and Adaptations
A 2024 study by Zoeller and Castro interviewed three teachers about their experiences with SoR and bilingual students. These educators questioned the application of the Simple View of Reading to Spanish literacy and the use of a monolingual approach with MLs. They noted a gap between the mandated curriculum and the instruction their students needed.
In a systematic review by Kittle et al. (2024), researchers confirmed teachers’ suspicions: first-language oral and reading proficiency significantly impact an ML’s English reading development. This finding shows the need to integrate first-language skills into SoR frameworks for MLs.
Policy Implications and Teacher Recommendations
As the READ ACT advances through the Senate, teachers of MLs urge policymakers to address key concerns. They advocate for including second-language and literacy development research in the SoR corpus, recognizing the importance of first-language skills, and removing the top-down implementation model that limits teacher flexibility.
Leave a Reply