Breaking
Parenting & Kids Education

Schools work to create safe environments

By Dexter Crane 5 min read
Schools work to create safe environments - safe environments
In Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the first level requires addressing physiological needs and safety, followed by love and belonging, esteem, and self-actualization.

Young people crave acceptance, yet that connection often slips away when they face emotional or physical insecurity—or when concealing their true selves becomes necessary to fit in. Dr. Becki Cohn-Vargas, a prominent expert on identity safety, defines it as the environment where students feel affirmed in their identities, thoughts, and emotions, free from constraints that force them to suppress who they are.

In Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, the first level requires addressing physiological needs and safety, followed by love and belonging, esteem, and self-actualization. However, in today’s climate, many schools are experiencing a climate of fear, affecting not only undocumented individuals but also immigrants with green cards and US citizenship, and entire school communities.

Creating a Safe Environment

Research demonstrates that a sense of belonging improves both academic and social outcomes. A large-scale school climate study found that when educators promote identity safety, respect for diversity, and belonging, students from all backgrounds achieve at higher levels. The Stanford Integrated Schools Project also found that students in identity-safe classrooms liked school more and scored higher on standardized tests.

In identity-safe classrooms, educators intentionally create a welcoming environment by validating students‘ identities and working to counter the harmful effects of othering. This can involve teaching respect for diversity and positive social skills, supporting students in standing up for themselves and others, and addressing microaggressions and bullying in ways that teach rather than punish.

The US Constitution guarantees that public schools provide a free education to all students, regardless of their immigration status. However, the presence of ICE agents outside schools has contributed to widespread fear and anxiety across communities. In response, many schools are taking proactive steps to create safer environments, such as passing Safe School Zone resolutions, stationing staff and volunteers to patrol the area, and providing trauma-informed care and counseling.

Some schools are also developing innovative solutions, such as rerouting buses to pick up children closer to home or creating “walking school buses” with teachers accompanying students to school. These actions increase physical safety and communicate that educators care deeply about students’ well-being.

Noticing Belonging

Dr. Cohn-Vargas emphasizes the importance of “noticing belonging” – paying attention to students’ facial expressions, body language, and nonverbal cues during interactions. By doing so, educators can cultivate a sense of belonging and provide support when needed. For example, a fifth-grade teacher used a simple yet effective strategy, asking students to rate their emotional state on a scale of 1-10, and then checking in with those who reported lower numbers.

Related Post: Students disengaged educators urged to revamp classrooms

In another example, a high school student named Daevy was struggling emotionally after her brother was deported. Her English teacher frequently criticized her, while her math teacher greeted her warmly and asked about her brother. By observing each child’s unique emotional responses, educators can offer encouragement and teach self-management skills to support emotional regulation.

Dr. Cohn-Vargas notes that a strong sense of belonging is created when multilingualism and students’ cultures are framed as assets. Opportunities to share their backgrounds should be woven into the curriculum throughout the year, not limited to holidays or heritage months. By doing so, educators can create a sense of belonging and validate students’ identities.

Small intentional messages that convey genuine care, such as micro-affirmations, can also play a significant role in creating a sense of belonging. For instance, a principal encouraged students to continue speaking their native languages at home, highlighting the importance of preserving cultural heritage. By using specific examples and acknowledging students’ efforts, educators can authentically recognize their growth and development.

According to Dr. Cohn-Vargas, the collective strength of schools draws from the diversity of voices, languages, and perspectives within them. By ensuring a safe and caring environment, supporting trusting relationships, teaching prosocial values, and affirming the rich intersections of many identities and backgrounds, educators can intentionally cultivate a sense of belonging and promote identity safety.

One educator, Chen, recalled that small intentional messages can have a profound impact on students’ lives. Her PE teacher’s recognition of her efforts to be inclusive shaped her to be intentional in her work as an educator, noticing who is at the table and creating space for contributions from those not traditionally part of the conversation. By noticing and responding to students’ sense of belonging, educators can create a positive and supportive learning environment.

Dr. Cohn-Vargas’ work emphasizes the importance of creating identity-safe classrooms, where students feel validated, supported, and motivated to learn. By promoting identity safety, respect for diversity, and belonging, educators can improve academic and social outcomes for all students. The research demonstrates that this approach can have a lasting impact on students’ lives, helping them develop the skills and confidence they need to succeed.

The Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC) provides resources and support for schools to create safe and welcoming environments for immigrant students and families. By working together, educators can create a positive and supportive learning environment that values diversity and promotes identity safety.

Dexter Crane

Deprecated: File Theme without comments.php is deprecated since version 3.0.0 with no alternative available. Please include a comments.php template in your theme. in /home/eduupi/public_html/wp-includes/functions.php on line 6260

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *