
From kindergarten to AP coursework, students must work effectively with diverse lesson partners and engage in class discussions. Anchor speaking and listening standards highlight the importance of rich, structured lesson interactions for college and career readiness.
Effective communication in task-based lessons requires more than a positive attitude and equal opportunity to speak. Standards-aligned interactions are typically not low-risk, informal conversations. Curriculum-embedded prompts often demand focused discussion or collaboration, including clear expression of ideas, comparison of thoughts, and building on others’ contributions using academic language.
Multilingual Learners Face Unique Challenges
Students learning a new language encounter significant auditory-processing and linguistic challenges during interactive assignments. They are frequently encouraged to “turn and talk” or “think-pair-share,” but the specific skills needed for productive listening in academic interactions are rarely taught, practiced, and monitored systematically.
English-speaking peers do not always model the behavior and communication skills required for complex literacy and problem-solving tasks. A careful analysis of the language demands of specific tasks is essential when designing lesson interactions for classrooms with Multilingual Learners.
For intermediate and secondary grades, mastering academic language is essential for content knowledge acquisition, literacy growth, and overall school success. Academic language encompasses concepts, technical terms, high-utility words, and specific language structures or grammar.
Research shows that school-age English Learners develop second-language skills more effectively when new forms are explicitly taught and practiced in meaningful lesson contexts. While students benefit from language tools introduced during dedicated English language development periods, core content teachers must also address key language functions and skills for lesson interactions.
Teaching Attentive Listening Skills to Multilingual Learners
Multilingual learners require explicit instruction in language functions to participate effectively in lesson interactions. Kate Kinsella emphasizes introducing and recycling formulaic expressions for attentive listening, such as comparing ideas and expressing agreement or disagreement. These expressions are taught in a complexity progression, starting with basic phrases and advancing to more sophisticated language forms. This approach reduces cognitive load and allows students to develop automaticity in using the language.
To clarify understanding, students learn to restate their partner’s idea and ask polite clarifying questions. They also practice affirming a peer’s contribution and projecting their voice during public speaking. Language objectives focused on attentive listening are incorporated into lessons, addressing speaking, listening, reading, and writing domains. “Frequent flyer” language objectives, aligned with ELD standards, complement content-aligned objectives and are recycled over time to reinforce learning.
Distinguishing Discussion from Collaboration
More complex peer-to-peer lesson assignments involve either productive discussion or collaboration. Speaking and listening standards often use terms like share, talk, conversation, discussion, collaboration, and interaction interchangeably, leading to confusion among learners.
To reduce anxiety, educators must be precise with language. For example, if partners are to brainstorm reasons for a character’s reaction, they should not be instructed to “collaborate.” If small groups are to solve a word problem using key terms, they should be explicitly directed to “collaborate,” not just “turn and talk.”
Both discussion and collaboration require staying on task, conveying ideas clearly, and listening respectfully. However, collaboration demands more, particularly in terms of accountable listening. It involves working together to create a mutually agreed-upon and jointly constructed response, solution, or project.
To support attentive listening, it’s vital to identify the types of tasks assigned within a course and the related language functions. Discussion and collaboration share foundational language functions like comparing and building upon ideas, agreeing and disagreeing, and restating or asking questions to ensure understanding.
Across grade levels and subjects, language learners can be expected to listen carefully to determine if their thinking aligns with their partner’s. During class discussions, they can compare ideas when called upon, avoiding repetition without accountability.
Early in the school term, basic formulaic expressions for comparing can be introduced, such as “My idea is like yours” or “My idea is the same as yours.” As students gain confidence, more advanced phrasing with subject-specific terms can be incorporated.
Another critical attentive-listening function is expressing agreement or disagreement politely. Accessible expressions can be taught and reused across subjects, enabling students to listen attentively and use these phrases effectively.
Multilingual Learners often find it challenging to express confusion politely. Teaching them to restate a partner’s idea to clarify understanding is a helpful starting point. Providing a set of statements and questions to express misunderstanding helps them engage in academic interactions more confidently.
In lessons supporting Multilingual Learners, language objectives should align with content-area standards and address the language needed to achieve lesson goals. These objectives cover speaking, listening, reading, and writing, reinforcing grade-level content instruction.
“Frequent flyer” language objectives, closely tied to ELD Standards, complement focal content-aligned objectives. A targeted toolkit addressing specific language functions can be reused over time, introducing new forms as students master previous ones.
Clearly displaying class discussion expectations is vital. Verbal directions alone can overwhelm students’ short-term memory. Visual supports, such as slides or posters, help students understand expectations for whole-class discussions, including attentive listening objectives.
A key speaking responsibility is projecting a clear voice. Many students speak softly during discussions due to lack of coaching or fear of mistakes. Encouraging them to raise their volume and emphasizing the importance of clear communication ensures their input is heard and valued.
Assigning note-taking tasks during discussions can be challenging for Multilingual Learners. Specifying a manageable active-listening and note-taking task, such as recording a standout idea, helps them focus on processing peers’ contributions while gradually building their note-taking skills.
Leave a Reply